top of page

POP SEMIOTICS

Balcony Concert #9 - An English Garden Party by London-based light lyric coloratura soprano Charlotte Hoather accompanied by George Todica. [Uploaded 24 May 2020]

Published May 28, 2020

Towards Which The Occupants of Our Gallery Raised Their Gaze

notes on the 2020 pandemic lockdown balcony concerts

by Jojo Soria de Veyra

California Violinists Marta Z performs Sunset Balcony Concert for Neighbors - Señorita, in which California-based electric aerial and dance violinist  Marta Z performs "Señorita" (Sam Mendes, Camila Cabello, etc.) for her neighbors. [Uploaded 5 May 2020 by Marta Z]

      HE lockdown balcony concerts phenomenon of 2020 started quickly, only a few days after the global lockdowns of March were put into effect.
  Two months later, while some of these lockdowns remained, the balcony concert proved that it has the staying power to qualify it as potentially a permanent fixture in the socio-psychology of two- or multi-story buildings in quarantines. This should be enough to bring the balcony, as an architectural feature, into the spotlight of cultural studies.
  You see, being on one’s front balcony (or one’s balcony facing a public area) is being both inside one’s house borders and outside it. While a balcony may be within a lot’s or building’s legal area, it may also be deemed as a house’s stretch that reaches out to the street in front of it or to the public area that it has access to. In fact, as a balcony is often a protrusion of a platform, supported by either console brackets or cantilevered beams, otherwise is supported by posts or columns, it may assume a right to be above a sidewalk or park area, and countries have different laws for buildings as regards to such protrusions above sidewalks or plaza areas. In certain homes, however, a balcony may just be a bashful sort, often called a Juliet’s balcony, while some houses of the wealthy would have no need for such protrusions as they may have enough space to turn a room fully into a loggia.
  Watching a bunch of people perch on a balcony also gives the viewer below a sense of that bunch's being up there (on the second floor or higher), but at the same time a sense of this group's being threatened by the law of gravity to at any point in time be suddenly down here (as might be the case with drunk elements moving about on balconies with balustrades reaching only up to their waistlines). In short, you could envy those on balconies for being at such a height and then be afraid for them, both at the same time. It is possible that your fear for them would overpower your envy of them.

T

Violinist Surprises her California Neighbors With Balcony Performance during quarantine - Hallelujah, in which Marta Z performs "Hallelujah" (Leonard Cohen). [Uploaded 29 April 2020 by Marta Z]

          HEN the sudden quarantine lockdowns of Q1 2020 reached the psyche of the inhabitants of the two- and multi-story buildings of our city and town neighborhoods, inhabitants who were not given enough time to stay in the open spaces at ground level below before getting "locked down," balconies collectively became these inhabitants' alternative park. What used to be a seldom-visited area to apartment owners wary of neighbors' gazes or the lure of gravity became a virtual booth for intra-neighbor personal conversations.
  Now, parks do have food. So neighbors devised ways of delivering or getting free or sold food via their balconies so that not everyone would need to be at street level. Here's one way in Naples by which residents of a neighborhood delivered food to recipients or otherwise took food from donors in the building (with the help of baskets and ropes):

W

Coronavirus: food baskets for vulnerable lowered from balconies in Naples. [Uploaded by Guardian News, 1 April 2020]

  But, wait. Parks also have shows. Now, one of the easiest shows to do on a balcony would be a musical performance (second only to a recitation of a poem). And so it came to pass that either musician inhabitants of a neighborhood decided to just come out and present themselves with a balcony performance to surprised captive eyes and ears, or elements from the neighborhood who knew a musician or singer in their block requested a performance from the talent therein for the community's bored benefit.
  Thus started the phenomenon, which would also automatically produce a flurry of YouTube and Facebook uploads seeking a wider audience for the purpose of sharing or promoting/self-promoting a talent or culture.
  In Peru, the ad agency Zavalita Brand Building even came up with an America's Got Talent-inspired contest for balcony concert video uploaders, which they called Balconies Got Talent. (See entry #7 of diskurso art magazine's May 2020 picks list). The contest ended on May 11.

       UT balconies have also always been a stage of sorts, because they're up there or across from another building; they are not within reach of their viewer.
  For the value of their being up there, as a platform much higher than the usual stage, we have witnessed use by such "performances" as the Pope's Urbi et Orbi on St. Peter's Basilica's front balcony or one dictator's speech from a palace hall. A church would also present the utter significance of its ceremonial music within its hall space by having this music performed (by a choir or set of musicians) from a balcony (known as the minstrels' gallery) placed either behind the churchgoers or at the church hall's sides; the music would not envelop you, the way evangelicals might have it for a participatory end, but rain on you from above.
  Balconies have also been a demonstration of wealth, property-wise. A loggia, for instance, would suggest a homeowner with plenty of floor space to spare. The same with the balcony with a patio garden surrounding a family-size dining table. More so for the balcony that is actually on the roof, presenting at best a roof garden. Meanwhile, a Juliet balcony (or balconet) would suggest either an owner's demand for a more private kind of balcony or one that would frugally not waste room space.
  With the lockdowns, however, even though a neighborhood may express the inclusion of buildings built for the block's wealthier citizens inside its zone as a snobbish part of that neighborhood, or though a building community might have wealthy and famous inhabitants in it occupying a unit or two in that building, the resultant collective park aura created by the balcony spaces during this pandemic period has subtly put away the wealth and social status differences and has focused everyone on rich talents instead, talents such as those shown by Charlotte Hoather and Marta Z in this page's embedded videos. Actually that's not even correct, for even talents that proved to be inadequate would still be appreciated by a neighborhood on their own terms, endearing their capacity to share whatever it is they have to a populace already tired of plugging their ears with too-polished Spotify material that's only been exacerbating their sense of isolation.
  In this sense, the balcony neighborhoods' concerts became their citizens' (temporary) new-normal karaoke joint of sorts, involving both awesome talents and struggling ones, both receiving applause and expressions of gratitude, rarely accompanied by a scoff that people could hear, we imagine.

B

Charlotte Hoather's Balcony Concert #6 - May Day, May Day. [Uploaded 1 May 2020]

           EANWHILE, balconies of expensive apartments not far from neighbors who would be in awe of such immoderation . . . have been touted by real estate brochures as spaces for their viewers to envy and for their owners to flaunt, advertently or not, as these spaces may intrinsically or readily or logically reflect an occupant’s high status in life, but high status their bearer may or may not choose to practice the flaunting of, or may choose to only intermittently flaunt this balconic value.
  The luxury of being perched on one of these open areas would be deemed similar to, although far more than, being on an outdoor table of a coffeehouse offering expensive coffee in an area where passersby workers would mostly be in awe of the high price of the house's brew and, needless to say, would naturally be envious of all persons having a sip there. Now, this expensive-café quality to a balcony could compare to the opera box in some theaters, that platform often reserved for dignitaries (towards whom the occupants in the gallery of that theater would every now and then be raising their gaze).
  But, again, understand that not all wealthy people want to flaunt their identities as wealthy elements of society, especially to an impoverished set of viewers. To this sort of individuals wary of publicly exposing their faces for long on their balconies, those open areas during the isolation may however have turned themselves into a sort of coming-out platform for a sudden pandemic neighborliness. We are presently reminded of that Manet painting titled The Balcony, where the subjects of the painting seem to have found it necessary to dress up before exposing themselves to the surrounding public.
  But, again, during the pandemic quarantine, the essence of balconies as symbols of status was almost erased, as we said above. Not only because such balconies would rarely be facing those of a squatted-on dilapidated building. Nor because most of these balconies' viewers were on similarly-valued balconies. It's because, as it would happen in any sort of lockdown instructing all inhabitants to shelter in place, any association of a balcony with its owner's money here quickly gave way to the focus on that neighborhood's being together in avoiding a common enemy, notwithstanding that that enemy could be in any one of them or on a surface or two somewhere among them.
  In short, the gatherings in these suspended parks include people who have collectively become no more than refugees hiding from an invisible, roaming adversary. Fortunately, though, their common fight with this enemy does not require them to be quiet. It only requires them to stay apart, even while they're together, allowed and able to be noisy in a balcony-to-balcony scene.  Why not, indeed, own this new sole freedom?
  This does provide a sort of contrast to the movie theater that had been capturing our eyes and ears by darkening the hall and then asking everyone to be silent before the house's featured treat starts on its unpredictable journey. This year's pandemic-lockdown balcony concerts captured their audience's eyes and ears and hearts simply through a symbolic darkening of the earth with a featured threat carrying the narrative of the unpredictability of illness' and death's whims.
  As much as it has been the performers, it was Disease, Death too, toward which the occupants of our gallery were raising their gaze and turning their ears. Otherwise they wouldn't be so forgiving to the neighborhood's lousiest singers, or be enduring novel constrictions that don’t allow them to ask for either a lowly signature or some sort of direct artist-and-patron connection while enjoying the privilege of being performed to by (newly-discovered) awesome talents. [d]

M

Jojo Soria de Veyra is a painter and critic and the editor of diskurso art magazine.
Citrus Fruits
Hide and Seek
Modern Architecture
bottom of page